cubicweb-tracker #1352144 prefix ticket absolute url with the project name [rejected]

Comments

• 2010/10/22 14:26, written by sthenault

  -1
  

  I don't want ticket's url to change when reaffected to another project.
  
  • 2010/10/22 14:27, written by pydavid

    This case have of course to be handled. But having the project name in the url would me much more informative url.
    • 2010/10/22 14:30, written by acampeas

      couldn't we handle:

      ticket/42/totor/0.2.0
      

      so as to satisfy both needs ? (here /totor/0.2.0 would be a purely informative piece without impact on ticket lookup)
      • 2010/10/22 14:36, written by pydavid

        project/babar/ticket/133742 contains the ticket eid so their is no issue for ticket lookup. if ticket 133742 move from babar to tortue we can either:

        • 301 redirect project/XXX/ticket/133742 to project/tortue/ticket/133742
        • ignore the project name in pratice
    • 2010/10/22 14:33, written by sthenault

      how would you handle it? And 'informative' url are useful when that
      makes it easy to remember them. It's not the case here, you still have
      to remember ticket's number.
      
      • 2010/10/22 14:36, written by acampeas

        I would handle it with a cute urlrewrite (or its brother) hack.

        If the project/version changed, I'd tell the user, as a bonus.

        The biggest obstacle is tolerance to obsolete information, from users.
      • 2010/10/22 14:46, written by pydavid

        An informative url is also usefull/important to recognise an url. With the project name the ticket url is less anonymous and help people to know what the url is about before opening it.

        apycot test execution url contains environment and test config name and the execution eid. This help people to know if they might be concerned by a pasted url.
        • 2010/10/22 14:48, written by pydavid

          the ticket part of the absolute url for example doesn't help to remember of lookup a ticket. It only help to recognise that this entity is a Ticket
  • 2010/11/04 19:32, written by nchauvat

    cool uris don't change. /ticket/12345 is the way to go. please reject this.
    • 2011/06/23 11:33, written by pydavid

      should this ticket be marked as "rejected ?